Scarborough Fair Restaurant, Sea Girt, NJ:
A Dining Review

Scarborough Fair Restaurant, Sea Girt, NJ

Scarborough Fair Restaurant
1414 Meetinghouse Road
Sea Girt, NJ

Restaurant Highlights

Fare:  American

Price:  Moderate - Expensive

Food Quality:  2 1/2 Stars

Service:  2 Stars

Decor:  2 1/2 Stars

Overall Rating:  2 1/2 Stars

Note:  Four star Rating System from 1/2 Star = poor to Four stars = Best in Class

A good place for quiet conversation and romantic dining

Value:  Good

Noise Level:  Low, good for quiet conversation

Dress:  Casual

Recommended For:  Diners who enjoy eclectic American food in a quiet, rustic setting.

Not Recommended For:  Diners who prefer casual dining with upscale, vibrant ambiance.

Recommended dishes:  When available, New Zealand Baby Rack of Lamb; Sauteed Grouper; and the Duck Breast a La Cervices .

Liquor:  A modest wine list of California and international wines.

Restaurant Review

Scarborough Fair is a rustic, charming restaurant located in an 1800’s restored farmhouse with an exterior that is attractively decorated with twinkling lights and a terraced brick sidewalk leading up to the entrance.

The restaurant, owned and operated by Mike Fontina who maintains a constant presence in the dining arear to ensure guests needs are taken care of.

The interior is cozy, dimly lit, with a series of multi level dining alcoves that have the feel of eating in a rustic, country ski lodge.

For a cozy, romantic dining experience, make a reservation for one of the quieter, private dining alcoves.

The menu is eclectic new American, with some flashes of creativity, though on a whole, the food is barely a notch above the many mediocre restaurants in the Central Jersey area.

The service is friendly and attentive, although short on supporting staff.

Scarborough Fair is open for lunch: Tuesday - Friday: 11:30am - 3:30pm
For Dinner: Tuesday - Thursday: 4:30pm - 9:00pm, Friday - Saturday: 4:30pm - 10:00pm, Sunday: 4:00pm - 9:00pm
Closed on Monday

Open Thanksgiving, Christmas Day, and New Years Day.

(updated: September, 2016)

How Do We Review (analyze) Restaurants?

New Jersey Leisure Guide strives to provide objective restaurant reviews .

The methodology used is research, analysis driven --- as opposed to that of a single restaurant critic or a viewer comment posting board.

Data is gathered from our viewers e-mail restaurant comments, Internet research, and professional restaurant critics. The data is sorted, (weeding out the obvious biased, "bone to pick",  and out of consensus comments), analyzed, and the review is created.

Learn More


Have a comment about what you just read! Leave a comment in the box below.