Catherine Lombardi Restaurant Review:
A must try spot in New Brunswick, NJ
Catherine Lombardi
3 Livingston Ave.
New Brunswick, NJ
⭐ Catherine Lombardi – Restaurant Review (New Brunswick, NJ)
🏛️ History & Ownership
Catherine Lombardi is named after the grandmother of one of the restaurant’s founders, whose family emigrated from Naples to Brooklyn. Her traditional Sunday and holiday cooking inspired the restaurant’s concept, which focuses on Neapolitanbased, Brooklyn, influenced Italian cuisine
The restaurant is part of the hospitality group that also operates Stage Left Steak, and both restaurants share a commitment to high-quality ingredients, warm hospitality, and a refined yet comfortable dining experience.
🍝 Food & Culinary Style
Cuisine
Catherine Lombardi serves Southern Italian cuisine with some crossover from Stage Left Steak, especially on shared dining nights.
Quality & Ingredients
- Fresh, farm-to-table quality ingredients are emphasized throughout the menu.
- House-made mozzarella, burrata, and fresh pasta dishes highlight craftsmanship and ingredient-driven cooking.
- Premium imported items such as Prosciutto di Parma and Jamon Iberico de Bellotta appear on the antipasti menu
Preparation & Style
The cooking style blends:
- Traditional Italian-American comfort dishes
- Neapolitan influences
- Modern plating and upscale execution
Signature Dishes (Based on Reviews & Menu Highlights)
- Wild Boar Bolognese with Pappardelle
- Chicken Francese (exceptional flavor and preparation)
- Eggplant Rollatini (noted as generous and well=executed)
- House made Mozzarella & Burrata
- Shrimp Scampi and classic antipasti selections
🎨 Ambiance & Atmosphere
Décor & Vibe
- Described as upscale, romantic, and cozy, ideal for special occasions
- Features two fireplaces, a cozy red interior, and a lively bar area
- Décor leans toward classic, ornate, and intimate rather than modern or industrial
Noise Level
Moderate, suitable for conversation without being too quiet or too loud
Table Spacing
Comfortable spacing that supports a relaxed dining experience
Scenic Views
No major scenic outdoor views; ambiance is driven by interior design rather than vistas.
Background Music
Eclectic music noted by diners, contributing to a warm, inviting atmosphere
Outdoor Dining
Seasonal outdoor seating is available through Stage Left Steak during spring and summer months
🤝 Service
- Attentive, professional, and knowledgeable staff
- Hostess and management noted for attentiveness and hospitality
- Consistent service quality across food delivery, pacing, and staff engagement
🍷 Other Factors
Alcohol & Bar Program
- Known for creative cocktails and fine wines
- Lively bar scene with a strong reputation for mixology
Child-Friendly?
Best suited for adults, date nights, and special occasions.
Recommended For
- Romantic dinners
- Theatergoers (located near New Brunswick performing arts venues)
- Wine and cocktail enthusiasts
- Celebrations and special occasions
Not Recommended For
- Budget-conscious diners (menu is priced in the upscale range)
- Those seeking casual, quick Italian fare
Parking
Typically supported by nearby city parking garages and street parking
Dress Code
Casual Elegant attire recommended
Private Parties
Offers private dining and wedding options through their event program
✅ What I Like About This Restaurant
- Strong commitment to Italian-American culinary heritage
- Warm, romantic ambiance with fireplaces and rich décor
- High quality ingredients and well executed dishes
- Excellent cocktails and wine list
- Professional, attentive service
🌟 What Sets Catherine Lombardi Apart
- A rare blend of heritage driven Italian cooking and upscale dining
- A deeply personal story rooted in family tradition
- A uniquely cozy, fireplace lit interior uncommon in modern Italian restaurants
- A strong cocktail and wine program that elevates the dining experience
Updated: December 2025
Our Restaurant Rating Criteria to Ensure Minimum Subjective Evaluation
