Blue Point Grill Restaurant Review:
A must try spot in Princeton, NJ
Blue Point Grill
258 Nassau St.
Princeton, NJ
⭐ Blue Point Grill Princeton, NJ — Restaurant Review
🏛️ History & Ownership
Blue Point Grill opened in 1999 as part of the Nassau Street Seafood & Produce Company family, a long established Princeton institution known for its commitment to fresh, sustainably sourced seafood.
🍽️ Food & Culinary Style
Blue Point Grill is recognized for fresh, simply prepared seafood served in generous portions and cooked with precision.
Cuisine & Ingredients
- Cuisine: American seafood with a focus on grilled, broiled, and pan-seared preparations.
- Ingredients: Sourced daily from trusted fishermen and handled through their own fish market, ensuring exceptional freshness
- Style: Minimalist, clean, ingredient-forward cooking that highlights natural flavors.
- Quality: Consistent freshness, portion size, and execution.
- Organic/Farm-to-Table: Not explicitly organic or farm-to-table, but strongly emphasizes sustainable seafood sourcing.
Signature Dishes
- Sweet chili shrimp
- Fried calamari
- Alaskan sablefish
- Jalapeño lime shrimp
- Crab-stuffed shrimp
- Costa Rican mahi mahi
- Risotto
The menu changes daily depending on the catch, which is a hallmark of serious seafood-driven restaurants.
🌿 Ambiance
Décor & Vibe
- Casual, bustling, and energetic
- Clean, simple décor with a focus on comfort rather than ornamentation
- Enclosed heated patio available year-round for reservations
- Outdoor rooftop and sidewalk seating available
Atmosphere Details
- Noise level: Moderate to lively during peak hours
- Table spacing: Typical of popular seafood restaurants—efficient but not cramped
- Scenic views: Street-level Princeton views; rooftop seating offers a more open-air experience
- Overall style: Casual coastal dining with Princeton charm
🤝 Service
- Friendly, welcoming staff
- Knowledgeable servers who explain menu items and seafood varieties
- Strong communication between front-of-house and kitchen
- Consistent food pacing
🍷 Other Factors
Alcohol & Bar Service
- Cocktails
- Wine
- Draft beer
- A well-rounded beverage menu that complements seafood
Child-Friendly?
Yes. The restaurant offers a kids’ menu with many good options
Recommended For
- Seafood lovers
- Date nights
- Families
- Groups
- Visitors seeking Princeton’s best-known seafood restaurant
- Guests who appreciate fresh, simply prepared fish
Not Recommended For
- Diners seeking quiet, intimate fine dining
- Those who prefer heavily sauced or highly experimental cuisine
- Guests who dislike seafood (menu is seafood dominant)
Parking
Parking can be challenging on Nassau Street. Options include:
- Street parking
- Nearby municipal lots
- Garage parking within walking distance
Dress Code
Casual to smart casual.
Private Parties
The restaurant accommodates groups and offers reservations for larger parties depending on availability.
💙 What I Like About This Restaurant
- Exceptionally fresh seafood sourced through their own market
- Consistent execution and generous portions
- A menu that changes daily based on the catch
- Friendly, knowledgeable staff
- Outdoor and enclosed patio dining options
- A Princeton staple with a loyal following
🌟 What Sets Blue Point Grill Apart
- Direct connection to Nassau Street Seafood, ensuring unmatched freshness and quality control
- Daily-changing menu driven by sustainable sourcing
- Longstanding reputation as one of Princeton’s top seafood destinations
- Simple, honest cooking that highlights the seafood rather than masking it
Our Restaurant Rating Criteria to Ensure Minimum Subjective Evaluation
