Tim McLoone's Supper Club, Asbury Park, NJ:
A Restaurant Review
Tim McLoone's Supper Club
1200 Ocean Avenue
Asbury Park, NJ
Tim Mcloone's Supper Club; Restaurant Highlights
Fare: New American
Price: Expensive
Food Quality: Fair, compared to other high end Asbury Park restaurants.
Service: Fair
Decor: Attractive decor with an "Old World" style supper club ambiance, and scenic beach front ocean views
Overall Rating: 2 Stars
Note: Four star Rating System from 1/2 Star = Poor to Four stars = Best in Class
Noise Level: Moderate - High
Dress: Casual
Recommended For: Older diners who enjoy an "Old World" supper club experience
Not Recommended For: Millennials who enjoy contemporary entertainment or budget conscious diners who prefer heavy sauce food preparations served in large portions.
Recommended dishes: When available, The Dry Aged Beef Filet with spinach, black truffle butter, and crispy mashed potato; and The NJ Caught Mahi Mahi with haricot verts, mashed potato, lemon sauce, and tomato comfit.
Liquor: Full Bar service
Tim McLoone’s Supper Club is one of several Tim McLoone-owned restaurants in New Jersey and at Maryland’s National Harbor.
Situated on the Asbury Park boardwalk, this well-known dining and entertainment venue is just steps away from three of McLoone’s other local spots: The Iron Whale, Robinson’s Ale House, and the newest addition, AP Rooftop.
Perched above Robinson’s Ale House, Tim McLoone’s Supper Club offers an upscale, “theatre-in-the-round” experience that blends dining with live entertainment. With a nostalgic vibe reminiscent of 1930s and '40s New York supper clubs, it's ideal for guests who enjoy dinner, dancing, and performances that often cater to a 50+ audience.
During warmer months, guests can enjoy ocean views from the balcony while dining for lunch or dinner.
The menu leans toward classic comfort food—featuring seafood, meats, and pasta—with a few vegan and gluten-free options. While the dishes are generally satisfying, they tend to lack innovation and flair.
As a live music venue, the Supper Club shines. The sound quality is solid, with video screens displaying the performance for added immersion. However, the volume can get quite loud depending on the act, making conversation a challenge.
Seating is close to the stage, creating an intimate concert feel, though the tables are tightly packed.
Open daily for lunch and dinner, the Supper Club also hosts special events—like a New Year’s Eve celebration that includes a four-course prix fixe menu, party favors, and a complimentary champagne toast at midnight.
(updated: April 2025)
Our Restaurant Rating Criteria to Ensure Minimum Subjective Evaluation
