Sirena Ristorante Dining Review:
A must try spot in Long Branch, NJ
Sirena Ristorante is a classical Italian restaurant with lots of ambiance and awesome, scenic oceanfront/beach views
Sirena Ristorante
27 Ocean Ave
Long Branch, NJ
Sirena Ristorante: Restaurant Highlights
Fare: Italian
Price: Moderate - Expensive
Food Quality: Well-executed menu, though creativity is substandard, the overall quality of the dishes is a notch above other popular Italian restaurants in the northern Jersey Shore.
Service: Depending on host(ess) sporadic attentiveness and friendliness
Ambiance/Decor: Stunning, scenic oceanfront, beach views, with seating near the fireplace in the colder months.
Overall Rating: 2 1/2 Stars
Note: Four-star Rating System from 1/2 stars= poor to 4 stars = Best in Class
Noise Level: Moderate - High
Dress: Casual
Recommended For: Diners who value trendy, ambiance, and scenic beach/ocean views with above average good Italian food
Not Recommended For: Large families with small children, budget-conscious diners.
Recommended dishes: When available, The Ipoglosso seared halibut with fingerling potato, shimeji mushrooms, haricot verts, clams, miso fumet, and pea shoots; The Veal Chop Milanese with arugula, cherry tomato, capers, onions, and grana padano; and The Pappardelle Bolognese with beef, veal, pork ragu, and mascarpone
Liquor: Good selection of reasonably priced wines and specialty cocktails. Bar scene is vibrant
Sirena Ristorante offers upscale Italian cuisine with breathtaking ocean views and a romantic ambiance, making it a standout destination for special occasions and refined dining. Known for its fresh ingredients, elegant décor, and attentive service, it’s ideal for couples, wine lovers, and beachside diners.
🌊 History & Vision
Sirena Ristorante is nestled in the heart of Pier Village, and has become a staple of the Jersey Shore dining scene. The restaurant was founded with a vision to blend classic Italian culinary traditions with modern elegance, offering guests a refined yet approachable experience. The establishment has maintained a loyal clientele through consistent quality and a commitment to excellence.
🍝 Food & Cuisine
Sirena specializes in Italian fare, with a menu that highlights fresh seafood, house-made pastas, and premium meats. Ingredients are sourced both locally and from Italy, ensuring authenticity and freshness. While not explicitly labeled as organic or farm-to-table, the emphasis on quality and seasonal ingredients is evident.
Signature dishes include:
- Bocconcini of Chicken Scarpariello with Sausage
- Fried Calamari with Peppers
- House-made ravioli and seafood risotto
The cuisine is artfully infused with classic Italian flavors, and the wine list—curated by an in-house sommelier—features rare and high-end bottles from around the world.
👨🍳 The Chef
Owned by chef turned restaurateur Joseph Cetrulo, who also owns Stella Marina and Cubacan restaurants in Asbury Park, under The Trinity Hospitality Group. The son of Italian parents, Joseph Cetrulo honed his culinary skills in Europe.
The kitchen team is known for elevating traditional Italian dishes with a modern twist.
🪟 Ambiance & Décor
Sirena’s ambiance is one of its most celebrated features. With floor-to-ceiling windows overlooking the Atlantic Ocean, the restaurant delivers stunning beachside views.
The décor is elegant and upscale, with touches of rustic charm and coastal sophistication. Seating near the fireplace adds warmth during colder months. Table spacing can be tight, and noise levels may rise during peak hourstic vibe, especially at sunset. Background music is subtle, allowing for conversation without distraction.
🧑🍳 Service
Service at Sirena is friendly, professional, and accommodating. Bartenders and waitstaff are knowledgeable about the menu and wine pairings, contributing to a smooth and enjoyable dining experience.
🍷 Other Features & Policies
- Alcohol/Bar Service: Full bar with an extensive wine list and craft cocktails.
- Child-Friendly: While not geared toward children, highchairs are available and the staff is accommodating.
- Recommended For: Romantic dinners, special occasions, wine enthusiasts, beachside dining.
- Not Recommended For: Large families with small children, budget-conscious diners.
- Parking: Available nearby in Pier Village; valet may be offered seasonally.
- Dress Code: Casual to upscale casual; beach attire not recommended.
- Holiday Hours: Sirena is open on Mother’s Day and other major holidays like Thanksgiving, Christmas, and Easter
🔧 What Needs Improvement
- Table spacing can feel cramped during busy hours.
- Noise levels may detract from the romantic ambiance.
- Menu creativity could be enhanced with more seasonal or innovative offerings
🌟 What Sets Sirena Apart
Sirena’s unmatched oceanfront views, sophisticated Italian cuisine, and romantic setting distinguish it from other Jersey Shore restaurants. Its wine program, curated by a sommelier, and commitment to quality ingredients elevate the experience beyond typical beachside dining.
Updated October 2025
Our Restaurant Rating Criteria to Ensure Minimum Subjective Evaluation
