Peter Shields Inn Restaurant Review:
A must try spot in Cape May, NJ
Peter Shields Restaurant
1301 Beach Dr.
Cape May, NJ
Prestigious "Best Restaurant" Recognition
Awarded to establishments earning 3 stars or higher for culinary excellence, service, and overall dining experience.
Peter Shields Restaurant Highlights
Fare: New American
Price: Expensive - Very Expensive
Food Quality: Well-executed, Uses fresh ingredients from local sources
Service: Professional, friendly, and attentive.
Ambiance/Decor: Set in a charming Georgian revival home. Charming, romantic "Old World", dining areas include a large fireplace, and dining on the enclosed sun porch
Overall Rating: 3 Stars
Note: Four star Rating System from 1/2 star = poor to 4 stars = Best in Class
Noise Level: Low - Excellent for quiet conversation
Dress: Upscale Casual
Recommended For:Romantic dinners, anniversaries, upscale dining
Not Recommended For: Young children, casual group outings
Recommended dishes: When available, The Berkshire Porkchop Milanese with South Philly Antipasto Salad, Roasted Peppers, Fresh Mozzarella, Soppressata, Aged Parmesan: The Lobster "Thermidor," with Sherry, Cognac, Parmesan, Potato Gnocchi, Sauce Americaine; and The Prime New York Strip Steak with King Crab Bearnaise, Aligot Potatoes
Liquor: Full bar service
Peter Shields Inn offers an elegant oceanfront dining experience with award-winning cuisine, refined service, and a romantic ambiance—ideal for special occasions and upscale getaways.
🏛️ History & Vision
Peter Shields Inn (PSI), a historic Georgian Revival mansion built in 1907, has long been a Cape May icon. PSI blends timeless elegance with modern hospitality. The restaurant’s vision centers on delivering refined, seasonal cuisine in a setting that celebrates Cape May’s coastal charm. Known for its romantic ambiance and elevated dining, PSI is a top choice for anniversaries, and gourmet getaways
🍽️ Food & Cuisine
PSI’s culinary program showcases American and international fare with a strong emphasis on seasonal, locally sourced ingredients. The menu features both à la carte options and a four-course chef’s tasting menu, with weekly specials that reflect fresh market finds
- Signature dishes include creamy tuna tartare, smoked salmon, white risotto, and sticky toffee pudding
- Preparation is classic with contemporary flair, often incorporating farm-to-table elements and organic produce when available.
- The wine list is extensive, PSI offers a full bar with spirits, wine, and beer.
👨🍳 The Chef
Helmed by Executive Chef Keith Mitchell, the kitchen delivers a seasonal New American menu that emphasizes fresh, locally sourced ingredients with artful presentation. A graduate of Philadelphia’s esteemed Restaurant School, Chef Mitchells style blends classic French technique with modern American innovation
🌅 Ambiance
PSI’s décor is elegant and romantic, with five intimate dining rooms and a scenic front porch overlooking the Atlantic Ocean. The vibe is refined yet welcoming, ideal for couples and upscale gatherings.
- Décor: Georgian architecture, white tablecloths, candlelight, and fresh flowers
- Noise level: Low to moderate—perfect for conversation
- Views: Oceanfront porch dining in warmer months
- Music: Soft background music enhances the serene atmosphere
- Table spacing: Comfortable and private
- Style: Ornate and timeless, not rustic or industrial
🤵 Service
The staff are gracious and knowledgeable. Service is attentive but unobtrusive, with a focus on consistency and professionalism.
📝 Other Details
- Alcohol: Full bar service; no longer BYOB
- Child-friendly: Children 12+ preferred; no highchairs or kids’ menu
- Recommended for: Romantic dinners, anniversaries, upscale dining
- Not recommended for: Young children, casual group outings
- Parking: On-site and street parking available
- Dress code: Business casual to formal
- Holiday hours: Open Thanksgiving, Christmas, Easter, and Mother’s Day
🌟 What Sets Them Apart
Peter Shields Inn stands out for its combination of historic charm, oceanfront views, and elevated cuisine. The chef’s tasting menu, romantic ambiance, and commitment to seasonal ingredients make it a premier destination in Cape May’s dining scene.
Updated October 2025
Our Restaurant Rating Criteria to Ensure Minimum Subjective Evaluation
