Old Homestead Restaurant, Atlantic City, NJ:
A Restaurant Review

Old Homestead Restaurant, Atlantic City, NJ

Old Homestead Restaurant
Borgata Hotel
Atlantic City, NJ

Restaurant Highlights

Fare:  Steak house

Food Quality:  3 1/2  Stars

Service:  3 1/2 Stars

Decor: 3 1/2 Stars

Overall Rating: 3 1/2 Stars

Note:  Four star Rating System from 1/2 Star = poor to Four stars = Best in Class

The top steak house on the Jersey Shore

One of the few high end steak houses in NJ that serves superior grade, USDA Prime beef.

Tables for 2 are close together and not suitable for cozy, quiet romantic dining.

Price:  Very Expensive

Value:  Good

Noise Level:  Moderate - High

Dress:  Upscale casual

Recommended For: Diners who enjoy excellent, superior grade steaks with upscale, old world charm and are willing to pay extra for the experience.

Not Recommended For:  Budget conscious diners who prefer simple food, lower prices or more casual dining.

Recommended dishes:  When available, The Gotham Rib Steak; The Sirloin Steak Au Poivre 18 oz.; and The New Zealand Baby Rack of Lamb.

Liquor:  Full Service Bar, extensive wine list, specialty cocktails.

Restaurant Review

The Old Homestead in the Borgata Hotel is popular with high rollers who are looking for the highest grade of beef in a big time atmosphere. The meal portions, the dining room ambiance, and the prices are all equally big time.

This is the best steak house on the Jersey Shore.

The decor is a warm contemporary atmosphere with soft lighting and earth tones --- not the traditional steakhouse with dark wood and clubby ambiance found in many other high end steakhouses.

Seating on the upper deck dining area provides a view down on the main dining area and a little more privacy. If you plan to dine with a group of 10-12, book the Chef's table. It's a glass-walled room in the kitchen with curtains you can open or close for privacy.

The Old Homestead is legendary for its USDA Prime, Texas-size slabs of beef and for their trademarked domestically raised, hand-massaged Kobe beef. The quality of their USDA Prime beef is of a higher quality than most other high end steak houses that serve USDA Choice.

Note: USDA Prime is the superior grade with exceptional tenderness, juiciness, flavor and fine texture. It has the highest degree of fat marbling and is derived from younger beef. That's why Prime is generally featured at the most exclusive upscale steakhouse restaurants.
USDA Choice is the second highest graded beef. It has less fat marbling than Prime. Generally USDA Choice will be less tender, juicy and flavorful with a slightly more coarse texture than Prime

The service is professional and attentive with old school charm.

Difficult to get reservations at peak times, reserve well in advance

The Old Homestead is open with seasonal hours
Summer Hours:
Monday - Thursday: 5:30pm – 10:30pm, Friday: 5pm - 11pm, Saturday: 5pm – 11pm, & Sunday: 5pm - 10:30pm

(updated: June, 2018)

How Do We Review (analyze) Restaurants?

New Jersey Leisure Guide strives to provide analytic restaurant reviews.

The methodology used is research, analysis driven --- as opposed to that of a single restaurant critic or a social media platform, viewer comment posting board.

Learn More