The Highlawn Restaurant Review:
A must try spot in West Orange, NJ
Prestigious "Best Restaurant" Recognition
Awarded to establishments earning 3 stars or higher for culinary excellence, service, and overall dining experience.
The Highlawn: Restaurant Highlights
Fare: New American
Price: Expensive
Food Quality: Well-executed inspirational, approachable menu.
Service: Professional, well trained, and attentive
Ambiance/Decor: Upscale, with stunning scenic views of the New York City skyline and Eagle Rock Park.
Overall Rating: 3 Stars
Note: Four star Rating System from 1/2 Star = poor to 4 stars = Best in Class
Noise Level: Moderate - High
Dress: Upscale Casual
Recommended For: Romantic dinners, anniversaries, business dinners, and holiday celebrations.
Not Recommended For: Budget-conscious diners or those seeking casual, quick meals.
Recommended dishes: When available, The Signature Slow Roasted Boneless prime cut; The Miyazaki prime sirloin steak; The roasted Branzino; and the 24-hour Bolognese
Liquor: Broad selection of wines and specialty cocktails. Bar scene is vibrant.
The Highlawn delivers a refined New American dining experience with breathtaking skyline views, seasonal cuisine, and a legacy of elegance—perfect for special occasions and upscale gatherings.
🌟 History & Vision
Perched atop Eagle Rock Reservation, The Highlawn is a historic landmark reimagined for modern fine dining. Formerly known as Highlawn Pavilion, the restaurant underwent a major revitalization under the Frungillo family, renowned for their hospitality ventures across New Jersey. Their vision: to blend timeless elegance with contemporary culinary excellence, making The Highlawn a premier destination for weddings, corporate events, and romantic dinners.
🍽️ Food & Cuisine
The Highlawn specializes in New American cuisine with French influences, emphasizing seasonal, locally sourced ingredients. The The kitchen's dishes showcase classic French technique with modern flair, focusing on flavor precision and elegant plating.
Signature dishes include: seared scallops, prime cuts of steak, and fresh seafood.
The menu evolves with the seasons, often featuring farm-to-table produce and sustainable proteins. The open kitchen and sushi bar add a contemporary twist to the dining experience
👨🍳 The Chef
Chef Maxime P. Kien, ACF, is a culinary force with accolades from luxury hotels and Michelin-starred kitchens. Born in the Côte d’Azur and trained across Europe and the U.S.—brings over 20 years of fine-dining expertise. His leadership at The Highlawn has elevated the restaurant’s profile
🌆 Ambiance & Setting
The Highlawn’s ambiance is upscale and romantic, with panoramic views of the NYC skyline and Eagle Rock Park. The décor blends classic elegance with modern touches, featuring:
- Spacious table arrangements for privacy
- Moderate to high noise levels during peak hours
- Outdoor dining with scenic vistas
- Background music that complements the refined atmosphere
It’s a popular venue for sunset dinners, milestone celebrations, and upscale date nights
🤝 Service
The staff are professional and attentive. While service is generally polished, there are apt to be occasional delays during busy periods. However, the team is responsive and eager to resolve issues, maintaining a high standard of hospitality.
🍷 Other Considerations
- Bar Service: Extensive wine list, with a growing focus on Italian vintages and craft cocktails.
- Child-Friendly: Best suited for adults and older children; not ideal for toddlers.
- Recommended For: Romantic dinners, anniversaries, business dinners, and holiday celebrations.
- Not Recommended For: Budget-conscious diners or those seeking casual, quick meals.
- Parking: Ample on-site parking available.
- Dress Code: Upscale casual—jackets encouraged but not required.
- Holiday Hours: Open on Thanksgiving, Christmas, Easter, and Mother’s Day
🔧 What Could Improve
Service timing can lag during peak hours, suggesting a need for better kitchen coordination.
🏆 What Sets The Highlawn Apart
- Unmatched views of Manhattan from a historic hilltop setting
- Chef-driven seasonal menus with French finesse
- A legacy of elegant hospitality and event excellence
For those seeking a memorable dining experience in North Jersey, The Highlawn offers a rare blend of culinary artistry, scenic beauty, and timeless charm.
Updated October 2025
Our Restaurant Rating Criteria to Ensure Minimum Subjective Evaluation
