Fins Bar and Grille, Cape May, NJ:
A Restaurant Review
Fins Bar and Grille
142 Decatur St
Cape May, NJ
Fins Bar and Grille: Restaurant Highlights
Fare: Modern American
Price: Moderate
Food Quality: Serves an extensive generic menu of sandwiches, burgers, salads, seafoods, with a raw bar.
Service: Friendly, attentive
Ambiance/Decor: Trendy, Open and modern with a bar area featuring an attractive blue wave glass lit bar with an impressive saltwater fish tank and the high back chairs.
Noise Level: Moderate
Dress: Casual
Overall Rating: 2 stars
Note: Four star Rating System from 1/2 Star = poor to Four stars = Best in Class
Recommended For: Diners who enjoy an extensive casual menu of comfort food, in an attractive, modern setting with a vibrant bar scene.
Not Recommended For: High end, fine dining patrons who enjoy a well- executed, creative menu prepared with a focus on fresh farm to table ingredients.
Recommended dishes: When available, The Lobster Roll with tender chunks of lobster sauteed in butter on a fresh toasted bun: The 10 oz. Angus Ground Beef Burgers; and The Hot Pastrami Sandwich with fried onions and Swiss cheese, served open faced on fresh baked marble rye.
Liquor: Bar scene is vibrant.
Fins Bar & Grille stands out from the typical "historic" Cape May eateries and local taverns. Despite what the name might suggest, this isn't your average bar-and-grill experience. Instead, you'll find a broad, diner-style menu packed with comfort food favorites—think burgers, sandwiches, tacos, seafood, and more—at approachable prices.
In 2024, Fins was acquired by the owners of the nearby Ugly Mug, bringing a refreshed menu with fewer entrées and a focus on casual, crowd-pleasing options.
During the warmer months, guests can enjoy outdoor dining and live entertainment, making it a great spot to soak in the seasonal vibes.
Inside, the vibe is trendy and modern. The bar area features a stunning blue wave-lit glass bar, high-back chairs, and an eye-catching saltwater fish tank. The dining room includes a cozy fireplace, perfect for a romantic meal—especially in the cooler off-season.
For the best ambiance, ask to sit by the fireplace or at a window seat across from it.
Fins offers live music on weekends, is kid-friendly with a dedicated children’s menu, and is open year-round (with seasonal hours).
During the summer, they’re open seven days a week for lunch and dinner.
Note: Reservations are not accepted, so plan accordingly.
(Updated April 2025)
Our Restaurant Rating Criteria to Ensure Minimum Subjective Evaluation
