Return to Homepage

Best Of NJ

Events & Festivals

Things To Do

Kids Attractions

Dining and Food

Romantic Attractions

Places to Stay

Have A Question?

NJ Information


Site Information

What is this?
Add to My Yahoo!
Add to My MSN
Add to Google

Sammys Ye Old Cider Mill
A Mendham, NJ Restaurant Rating and Review

Sammys Ye Old Cider Mill
353 Mendham Road West (Route 24) Mendham, NJ
(973) 543-7675

Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill


Price Expensive
Fare Steakhouse

Restaurant Ratings

Overall Rating N/A
New Jersey Leisure guide is the largest single source of complete and impartial NJ restaurant reviews.

Unlike other sources that review restaurants on the basis of a single visit by a restaurant critic, or on the basis of restaurant diners, our restaurant ratings and reviews take into account a wider audience and are the result of a compilation of many sources, including restaurant critics and diners who have eaten there. Learn more about the process we use to rate New Jersey restaurants.


Restaurant Review

This very popular casual eatery is not for everyone and offers a very unique eating experience with people either loving it or hating it. If nothing else, this will be a restaurant experience that is hard to duplicate in New Jersey, and will not be easily forgotten.

Do not expect to drive up to a place that looks like a restaurant as there is no sign out front and the interior and feels like a 1940', 50's VFW hall. This former prohibition era speakeasy continues to operate like one, and in addition to not having a sign out front, there is a bar & game room in the basement, reminiscent of the old speakeasy's.

Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill is a long time favorite in the local scene, people come here for good food and an unpretentious, and unusual experience, with very friendly service. Also a popular place for families with kids who enjoy the downstairs bar and game room. Come early on weekends or you can expect long delays.

As you enter, you place your order "family style" then head downstairs, while you wait until your name is called. While waiting downstairs, you can play a game and have a drink at the bar and watch TV until your name is called, then you head backup stairs to retrieve your food.

The menu at Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill features outstanding steaks and lobsters, though somewhat pricey, it is also one of the main reasons diners come here. The remaning entree menu selections are also very good and include lamb, pork, fresh fish, and pasta dishes. All selections include a salad, vegetable, french fries, dessert and coffee, though the desserts are not as good as the main entree selections. The menu also lists smaller portion, child size selections.

Page copy protected against web site content infringement by Copyscape

Subscribe to our free monthly newsletter. Receive notice of upcoming events, seasonal places to visit, and restaurant information.




Don't worry -- your e-mail address is totally secure.
I promise to use it only to send you New Jersey leisure guide news.


Fine Dining
Restaurant Ratings

No Stars Below average

One star


Two stars

Above Average

Three stars


Four stars

Best in Class

 N/A = A casual dining eatery, not rated as a fine dining restaurant 

Rate Your Favorite New Jersey Restaurant

Wine Enthusiast - 125 x 125 

New Jersey Theatres
Performing Arts Venues


Site Search

Looking for something?
Find It Here!

footer for New Jersey page