Nonnas Citi Cucina Restaurant Review: A must try spot in Englishtown, NJ
Nonna's Citi Cucina
448 Rte 9 N
Englishtown, NJ
Nonna's Citi Cucina blends elevated Italian comfort food with a warm, modern dining atmosphere perfect for date nights, family gatherings, and celebrations. With scratch-made dishes, attentive service, and a stylish yet inviting ambiance, it stands out as one of Monmouth County’s most reliable and romantic Italian dining destinations.
Food: Cuisine, Style & Signature Dishes
Fare: Classic Italian-American fare with a contemporary twist
Price: Moderate
Signature Dishes: Short Rib Pappardelle – slow-braised, tender, deeply savory. Chicken Sinatra with mushrooms, prosciutto, and a rich marsala reduction. Seafood Fra Diavolo – bold, spicy, and loaded with fresh shellfish. Brick-Oven Pizzas – crisp, blistered crusts with gourmet toppings.
Food Quality & Preparation: Generous, shareable portions. Sauces made in-house daily. Fresh herbs and aromatics used liberally. Balanced seasoning and consistent execution across the menu. Comfort-driven plating—rustic, hearty, and visually appealing.
Ambiance: Décor, Vibe & Atmosphere
Nonnas Citi Cucina offers a warm, contemporary Italian aesthetic that blends rustic charm with modern touches.
Décor & Vibe
- Earthy tones, stone accents, and dark woods.
- Soft lighting that creates a romantic glow in the evenings.
- A mix of rustic Italian charm and modern industrial chic.
- A stylish bar area with backlit shelving.
- Spacious dining room with comfortable booth seating.
- Occasional seasonal décor that enhances the cozy feel.
Noise Level & Table Spacing
- Moderate noise—lively but not overwhelming.
- Tables spaced comfortably for conversation.
- Booths offer added privacy for date nights.
Music
Soft background music that complements the dining experience without overpowering conversation.
Service: Welcoming & Consistent
- Warm and welcoming from the moment you enter.
- Knowledgeable, especially regarding wine pairings and menu recommendations.
- Efficient and consistent, even during peak hours.
- Staffed by a team that clearly values hospitality and repeat customers.
Other Factors
Alcohol & Bar Service
- Full bar with specialty cocktails.
- Strong wine list featuring Italian and California selections.
- Popular for happy hour and pre-dinner drinks.
Child-Friendly?
Yes—large portions, kid-friendly pasta dishes, and a relaxed atmosphere make it suitable for families.
Best For:
- Romantic date nights
- Family dinners
- Celebrations and birthdays
- Casual weeknight meals
- Drinks and appetizers at the bar
Not Ideal For
- Diners seeking ultra-quiet, fine-dining formality
- Strictly organic or farm-to-table purists
Parking
- Ample parking in the shared plaza lot.
- Easy access from major local roads.
Dress Code
Smart casual is the norm.Comfortable but polished attire fits the vibe.
What I Like About Nonnas Citi Cucina
Nonnas Citi Cucina shines because it delivers comfort, consistency, and atmosphere all in one place. The food is hearty and satisfying, the ambiance is warm and romantic without being pretentious, and the service feels genuinely welcoming. It’s the kind of restaurant where you can celebrate a milestone or simply unwind after a long week.
What Sets Them Apart
- Reliability: You know the meal will be good every time.
- Atmosphere: A perfect blend of cozy and modern—ideal for couples.
- Generous Portions: Excellent value for the quality.
- Versatility: Works for date nights, families, and celebrations alike.
- Community Favorite
Updated January 2026
Our Restaurant Rating Criteria to Ensure Minimum Subjective Evaluation
