The Best Dining Spots in Spring Lake, NJ

Spring Lake Nj Restaurants

Best Restaurants in Spring Lake, NJ: Top Places to Eat in Every Category

Spring Lake, NJ—often called the “Jewel of the Jersey Shore”—is known for its charming downtown, pristine beaches, and exceptional dining scene. Whether you're planning a romantic night out, a family meal, or a casual bite after the beach, this guide highlights the best restaurants in Spring Lake across every major dining category.

.

Fine Dining in Spring Lake, NJ

Whispers Restaurant

Whispers is an elegant, Victorian-style fine-dining restaurant located inside the historic Hewitt-Wellington Hotel in Spring Lake. Known for refined service and beautifully crafted dishes, it offers one of the most intimate dining experiences at the Jersey Shore

  • Fare:Contemporary American cuisine
  • Best For: Special occasions and celebrations. Romantic dinners, Quiet, intimate evenings
  • Signature Dishes: Lobster Crepe. Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes. Mozzarella Burrata. Pan-Seared Salmon Filet. Pistachio-Crusted Halibut. Filet Mignon and Lamb ChopsAmbiance: Situated inside the Hewitt-Wellington Hotel, enhancing its historic Victorian charm with crystal chandeliers, silver service, and white linens. Cozy, elegant, and intimate — ideal for a refined, quiet dining experience. Located lakeside within a historic boutique hotel, adding to the romantic feel
  • Why It Stands Apart: Whispers distinguishes itself through its blend of Victorian elegance, intimate scale, and elevated American cuisine. The BYOB format with premium glassware adds a unique, upscale-yet-personal touch, while consistently praised dishes and attentive service create a dining experience that feels both special and timeless.

Scan the Whispers Restaurant Website

Amelia’s By the Sea

A refined oceanfront restaurant blending old school Italian warmth with contemporary continental cuisine, set inside the historic Grand Victorian Hotel. With sweeping Atlantic views and dishes made to order from fresh, locally sourced ingredients, it delivers a coastal dining experience that feels both elevated and inviting.

  • Fare: Italian & contemporary continental cuisine
  • Best For: Romantic dinners and special occasions, Celebrations, private events, and family gatherings
  • Signature Dishes: Sea bass, Pork chops, available with gluten-free pasta, Daily specials
  • Ambiance: Elegant, oceanfront dining room with a beautifully renovated interior and panoramic views of the Atlantic. Cozy, warm, and welcoming atmosphere. Heated outdoor porch for year-round seaside dining
  • Why It Stands Apart: Amelia’s By the Sea distinguishes itself through its combination of oceanfront elegance, made-to-order cuisine, and a family run dedication to hospitality. Formerly Bareli’s by the Sea, it maintains the same beloved menu and service while elevating the experience with fresh creativity, personalized attention, and one of the most picturesque dining settings on the Jersey Shore.

Scan the Amelia’s By the Sea Restaurant Website


The Breakers on the Ocean – Sea Crest Grille

An elegant oceanfront dining destination offering classic American and Northern Italian cuisine with sweeping views of the Atlantic. Known for its relaxed sophistication, it blends coastal charm with consistently well crafted dishes.

  • Fare: Classic Northern Italian
  • Best For: Oceanfront dining with panoramic views. Romantic dinners and special occasions. Weekend getaways for stay and dine experiences
  • Signature Dishes: Fresh seafood specials (rotating daily), Prime steaks and veal chops grilled to order. Classic Northern Italian entrées such as chicken marsala and filet-style preparations
  • Ambiance Elegant yet casual oceanfront setting with a wrap around porch overlooking the Atlantic. Sunny veranda for breakfast and lunch with views of the pool and ocean. Piano lounge offering cocktails, appetizers, and desserts in a refined atmosphere. Cool, relaxed coastal décor with a classic Jersey Shore charm
  • Why It Stands Apart: The Breakers on the Ocean – Sea Crest Grille distinguishes itself with its rare combination of true oceanfront dining, a historic Spring Lake setting, and a menu that balances classic Northern Italian flavors with fresh coastal cuisine. Its multiple dining spaces—from veranda to porch to piano lounge—create a versatile experience that feels both timeless and uniquely Jersey Shore.

Scan the Breakers on the Ocean – Sea Crest Grille Restaurant Website

Olea

Olea Restaurant brings refined Mediterranean inspired coastal dining to the heart of Spring Lake. Known for its fresh ingredients, warm hospitality, and elegant yet relaxed atmosphere, it’s a standout on the Jersey Shore.

  • Fare: Modern Mediterranean with coastal influences
  • Best For: Date nights, Upscale yet approachable family dinners, Celebratory meals. Food focused travelers exploring Spring Lake, Winecentric evenings
  • Signature Dishes: Seared branzino with lemon herb accents, House made pasta with seasonal vegetables or seafood, Mediterranean mezze selections, Olive oil forward dishes that highlight the restaurant’s namesake
  • Ambiance: Warm, polished, and intimate—soft lighting, coastal chic décor, and a relaxed elegance that fits perfectly with Spring Lake’s refined beach town charm.
  • Why It Stands Apart: Olea blends the sophistication of a destination restaurant with the comfort of a neighborhood favorite. Its Mediterranean coastal focus, commitment to fresh ingredients, and consistently warm hospitality make it one of Spring Lake’s most memorable dining experiences.

Scan the Olea Restaurant Website

Best Taverns, Pubs & Sports Bars

St. Stephen’s Green Publick House

A beloved Spring Lake Heights institution, St. Stephen’s Green Publick House delivers authentic Irish hospitality with hearty, elevated pub fare. Known for its warm atmosphere and lively spirit, it’s one of Monmouth County’s most popular dining spots.

  • Fare: Authentic Irish cuisine with American pub influences
  • Best For: Casual dinners with friends. Lively nights out with music and drinks. Families seeking relaxed, hearty meals. Anyone craving authentic Irish pub culture
  • Signature Dishes: Emerald Isle Mussels in herb cream sauce. Irish Kettle Chips with bacon, cheddar & bleu cheese. Twin Crab Cakes with sweet corn purée. Lamb chops
  • Ambiance: Classic Irish pub atmosphere with warm woods, fireplace, lively bar energy, and a friendly, welcoming staff. Casual and comfortable dining room; lively bar area with music and conversation. Cozy, neighborhood gem feel that makes guests feel at home
  • Why It Stands Apart: St. Stephen’s Green Publick House distinguishes itself through its deep Irish roots, authentic fare, and genuinely warm hospitality. Its combination of elevated pub dishes, lively entertainment, and a true neighborhood pub atmosphere has made it one of Monmouth County’s most beloved dining destinations.

Scan the St. Stephen’s Green Publick House Restaurant Website

Spring Lake Tap House

A lively, modern gastropub in Spring Lake Heights serving elevated comfort food, craft beers, and crowd-pleasing classics. Perfect for casual meals, game days, and relaxed gatherings with friends and family.

  • Fare: American gastropub cuisine
  • Best For: Watching the big game with a crowd. Happy hour and casual drinks. Families and groups of all sizes. Dog friendly outdoor dining in warm weather
  • Signature Dishes: Blackened Steak Bites. Ultimate Nachos. Whiskey Glazed Flat Iron Steak. Buffalo Chicken Pizza & other specialty pies. Cookies & Cream Pancakes (brunch)
  • Ambiance: Energetic, friendly neighborhood pub vibe. Spacious indoor dining room and lively bar. Outdoor patio with games like cornhole and giant Connect Four. Casual, welcoming, and kid friendly
  • Why It Stands Apart: Spring Lake Tap House blends the comfort of a neighborhood pub with an unexpectedly diverse, elevated menu. Its combination of great food, a robust drink lineup, family friendly atmosphere, and a fun, game day energy makes it a standout gathering spot at the Jersey Shore.

Scan the Spring Lake Tap House Restaurant Website

Best Seafood Restaurant in Spring Lake

Spring Lake Seafood

Spring Lake Seafood brings the freshness of the Jersey Shore straight to the plate with a focus on high quality, locally sourced catches. It’s a polished yet relaxed coastal dining spot perfect for seafood lovers who appreciate clean flavors and thoughtful preparation.

  • Fare: Modern American seafood with a strong emphasis on local, seasonal fish and shellfish
  • Best For: Seafood enthusiasts, Date nights and special occasion dinners, Upscale casual nights out at the Shore, Visitors looking for a refined but approachable Spring Lake dining experience
  • Signature Dishes: Fresh local oysters and rotating raw bar selections, Pan seared scallops with seasonal accompaniments, Lobster rolls and lobster entrées, Crispy calamari and classic seafood starters.
  • Ambiance: Coastal chic with clean lines, soft lighting, and a polished but welcoming feel. Intimate dining room that balances upscale style with Shore town warmth. A relaxed, grown up atmosphere ideal for lingering over a glass of wine
  • Why It Stands Apart: Spring Lake Seafood distinguishes itself by treating seafood with respect—letting freshness, quality, and clean preparation shine without unnecessary embellishment. It offers the kind of elevated coastal dining that feels both special and effortlessly Jersey Shore, making it a standout choice for visitors and locals who want seafood done right.

Scan the Spring Lake Seafood Restaurant Website

Best Casual Family Restaurants

Benny’s Pizza & Restaurant

A beloved Spring Lake staple, Benny’s Pizza serves classic Jersey style pies with a hometown feel. It’s the kind of spot where locals gather, families unwind, and every slice tastes like tradition.

  • Fare: Italian comfort dishes
  • Best For: Families looking for an easy, satisfying meal, Beachgoers grabbing a post shore bite, Locals craving reliable, well priced pizza, Casual date nights or quick takeout
  • Signature Dishes: Classic thin crust cheese and pepperoni pies. Margherita pizza with fresh mozzarella and basil, Chicken parm sub. Garlic knots and house made marinara
  • Ambiance: Relaxed, welcoming, and unfussy—think neighborhood pizzeria with friendly counter service. A mix of dine in tables and steady takeout traffic, giving it that lively, small town energy.
  • Why It Stands Apart: Benny’s Pizza shines because it stays true to what a Jersey Shore pizzeria should be: simple, dependable, and delicious. It’s the kind of place where the pies taste the same every time—in the best possible way—and where both locals and visitors feel instantly at home.

Scan the Benny’s Pizza & Restaurant Website

Jose’s Mexican Restaurant

A beloved Spring Lake staple, Jose’s Mexican Restaurant serves comforting, authentic Mexican cuisine with a warm, family run touch. It’s the kind of place where locals return weekly and visitors feel instantly at home.

  • Fare: Traditional Mexican comfort food
  • Best For: Casual family dinners, Takeout nights, Groups looking for hearty, satisfying plates, Anyone craving authentic, unfussy Mexican cooking
  • Signature Dishes: Chicken, steak, or shrimp fajitas served sizzling hot. Enchiladas with rich, house made sauces. Burritos and chimichangas. Fresh guacamole and warm chips. Classic tacos with your choice of protein
  • Ambiance: Cozy, colorful, and welcoming—think relaxed neighborhood spot with a friendly staff, festive décor, and a come as you are vibe. It’s comfortable, lively, and perfect for families or casual date nights.
  • Why It Stands Apart: Jose’s stands out because it delivers exactly what people love about a great local Mexican restaurant: honest flavors, hearty plates, and a warm, personal touch that chain restaurants can’t replicate. It’s a Spring Lake favorite for good reason—simple, satisfying, and always welcoming.

Scan the Jose’s Mexican Restaurant Website

Best Breakfast in Spring Lake

Honey Berry Café

Honey Berry Cafe brings a bright, modern brunch experience to Spring Lake with generous portions, fresh ingredients, and a warm neighborhood vibe. It’s the kind of spot where families, couples, and weekend wanderers settle in for comfort food with a creative twist.

  • Fare: Elevated breakfast and brunch
  • Best For: Brunch lovers, Families and multigenerational groups, Casual dates, Post beach meals, Visitors exploring downtown Spring Lake
  • Signature Dishes: Fluffy berry topped pancakes and French toast. House made omelets and skillets. Avocado toast with fresh toppings. Specialty lattes and cold brews. Fresh baked pastries and muffins
  • Ambiance: Bright, airy, and cheerful. Modern café décor with cozy seating. Relaxed, family friendly energy. A welcoming neighborhood feel that fits Spring Lake’s coastal charm
  • Why It Stands Apart: Honey Berry Cafe stands out for delivering big city brunch creativity with small town warmth. Its combination of fresh ingredients, vibrant plates, and a sunny, inviting atmosphere makes it a go to brunch destination for locals and visitors exploring the Jersey Shore.

Scan the Honey Berry Café Restaurant Website

Plan Your Perfect Meal in Spring Lake

Whether you're craving fresh seafood, a romantic fine-dining experience, a hearty pub meal, or a family-friendly pizza night, Spring Lake offers exceptional dining options for every taste. Use this guide to plan your next meal and enjoy the best of the Jersey Shore’s culinary scene.