Monticello At Red Bank

A Red Bank NJ Dining Review

Gaetano's  Restaurant


Monticello At Red Bank
69 Broad Street
Red Bank, NJ 07701-1946
(732) 450-0255




Restaurant Highlights

Fare: Italian American - with Mediterranean influences.

Price: Moderate - Expensive

Food Quality:



Overall Rating:

Note: Four star Rating System from no stars = poor to Four stars = Best in Class

thumbs up Well prepared Italian food with a Mediterranean influence

thumbs downWait staff while friendly and attentive, could use improvement with a better knowledge of the menu.

thumbs down Large party bookings can create a very high noise level and over-whelm diners at nearby tables.

Value: Good

Noise Level: Moderate - High

Dress: Casual

Recommended For: Diners who enjoy southern Italian food in a low key setting.

Not Recommended For:
Budget conscious diners who may prefer simpler food and lower prices.

Recommended dishes: When available, The Black Angus Fresh Cut of the Day Au Poivre; The Gnocchi Monticello: and The Fresh Catch of the Day Putanesca.

Liquor: BYOB -Though they offer a limited selection of Domenico California Wines


Restaurant Review


The Monticello, a small BYOB restaurant in Red Bank, serves up good Italian food with French, Asian, Spain, and European influences.


They are owned by brother and sister team Roberto and Katerina Giambalvo with Katerina serving as the Chef.


Chef Katerina received her culinary training at the French Culinary Institute of New York. Her previous experience has been as a chef for Monticello in Middlesex County.

The decor is attractive, with soft earth toned walls adorned with white ceramic masks on one wall, and Italian-themed paintings on the other, with soft, dim lighting to set the mood.


However, the tables are placed very close, especially along a long wall, and the noise level can get very high. Not recommended if you are looking for a cozy, quiet dining experience.


Monticello doesn't have a liquor license, but if you forget to bring your own they'll give you a wine list to order from a nearby wine store. The wines are reasonably priced and will be promptly delivered to your table.


While the food overall is good, with many other good Italian restaurants in Red Bank, they have done little to distinguish themselves from the others.


They offer an excellent value, 3 course Prix menu on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday & Sunday from 3:30pm until 9:00pm


During the warmer months there is outdoor sidewalk dining


Monticello is open six days/week for dinner and Sunday brunch.

For dinner: Tuesday - Thursday 3:30 PM - 9 PM, Friday - Saturday: 3:30 PM - 10 PM & Sunday 3:30 PM - 9 PM
For Sunday Brunch: 11 AM - 3:30 PM


(updated: May, 2015)


How Do We Rate and Review Restaurants? 

New Jersey Leisure Guide contains the largest source of extensive and unbiased New Jersey restaurant reviews. Data is gathered from our viewers e-mail restaurant comments, Internet and print research, and professional restaurant critics. The data is analyzed and a review created. Staff personal visits are sometimes made to corroborate and/or tweak results.

read more

Other New Jersey Resources

Red Bank

Red Bank  restaurants

Discover the popular Red Bank restaurants with ratings and reviews.


read more

Red Bank
Visitors Guide

Red Bank,  New Jersey

Learn about the many attractions in Red Bank, the Jersey Shore’s cultural, social and commercial destination.


read more

Best Family

Family  restaurants in  New Jersey

For diners who are looking for a family dining experience that offers enjoyment for both parents and kids.


read more

Best Breakfast and Sunday Brunch

New Jersey Breakfast and Brunch RestaurantsSunday breakfast and brunch dining selections for families of all budgets looking to celebrate a special occasion and are especially popular for celebrating Easter, Mothers Day, Fathers Day and other occasions

read more

entertainment book

Groupon Getaways

Subscribe to our Free
Monthly Newsletter

Email Address