Discover the Charm of Ye Olde Centerton Inn, Pittsgrove,NJ: A dining review

Ye Olde Centerton Inn, Pittsgrove, NJ

Ye Olde Centerton Inn
1136 Almond Road
Pittsgrove, NJ

Ye Olde Centerton Inn: Restaurant Highlights

Fare:  American

Price:  Moderate - Expensive

Food Quality: Well-executed menu, creatively prepared using seasonal, locally grown ingredients

Service: Welcoming, friendly, attentive

Decor: Charming ambiance set in an historic Circa 1706, 18th century building with six dining rooms and a cozy fireplace.

Overall Rating:  2 Stars

Note:  Four star Rating System from 1/2 Star = poor to Four stars = Best in Class

Noise Level:  Moderate, making it comfortable for conversation.

Recommended For:  Couples seeking a romantic, historic setting. Families celebrating milestones or holidays, and food lovers who enjoy traditional American fare with generous portions.

Not Recommended For:  Diners seeking modern, eclectic, or trendy cuisine, and those preferring fast-casual dining, as this is a sit-down, reservation-based experience.

Liquor: Curated wine list, seasonal beers, and expertly mixed cocktails.

The Olde Centerton Inn is a historic dining destination (est. 1706) known for its classic American cuisine, cozy ambiance, and attentive service. It’s ideal for diners who appreciate tradition, hearty meals, and a warm atmosphere, though less suited for those seeking trendy or eclectic fare.

🏛 History

  • Founded in 1706, the Olde Centerton Inn is one of South Jersey’s oldest continuously operating restaurants.

  • The building retains its 18th-century charm, with six dining rooms and a fireplace that highlight its colonial heritage.

  • Over centuries, it has evolved from a local tavern into a celebrated fine-dining establishment, blending history with modern hospitality.

🍽 Cuisine

  • Specializes in steaks and seafood, prepared with locally sourced ingredients.

  • Menu highlights include:

    • Perfectly cooked steaks and prime rib

    • Pasta Primavera and fresh salads with bold flavors

    • Homemade rolls, bread pudding, lemon pie, and pound cakes for dessert

🌟 Ambiance

  • Charming, historic décor with wood accents and cozy fireplaces.

  • Peaceful, homey atmosphere ideal for anniversaries, weddings, or intimate dinners.

🤝 Service

  • Staff are welcoming, friendly, and attentive.

  • Reservations are recommended due to staffing limitations, but service remains prompt and professional.

🔧 Improvements Needed

  • Menu variety could expand to include lighter, contemporary options for broader appeal.

  • Staffing challenges occasionally limit availability, so ensuring consistent coverage would enhance guest confidence.

✨ Why It’s Special

  • Historic significance: Few restaurants can claim over 300 years of continuous operation.

  • Authentic atmosphere: Dining here feels like stepping back in time while enjoying modern culinary artistry.

  • Community pride: The Inn celebrates South Jersey by sourcing local ingredients and offering a warm, family-style experience.

Updated November 2025