Tuckers Tavern Review:
A must try spot in Long Beach Island, NJ

A restaurant Review of Tuckers Tavern, LBI, NJ

Tuckers Tavern
101 S West Ave
Beach Haven, NJ

Fare: Coastal Gastro Pub

Price: Expensive

Food Quality: Creative, hearty, and comforting.

Service: Friendly, attentive

Ambiance/Decor: Upscale rustic, nautical ambiance

Liquor: Vibrant Full-Service Bar. Features craft beers from top breweries including Victory, Dogfish Head, Yards, Rogue, Stone, with over 20 draft beers.

Overall Rating: 2 1/2 Stars

Note: Four-star Rating System from 1/2 star = poor to Four stars = Best in Class

Recommended For: Groups, couples, and tourists seeking vibrant, scenic dining, Happy hour enthusiasts and seafood lovers

Not Recommended For: Diners preferring quiet, BYOB, or low-key family-style settings

Recommended dishes: When available, The Pan Roasted Local Scallops French lentils, muhammara, curried cauliflower, torn mint, pomegranate; The Grilled Center Cut Filet Mignon with crispy garlic & chive potatoes, asparagus, wild mushroom demi: and The Wild Local Tuna jasmine rice cake, miso charred broccolini, sweet soy - lime vinaigrette.

Tuckers Tavern offers upscale coastal pub fare with a nautical ambiance, a vibrant bar scene—ideal for lively gatherings and scenic waterfront and sunset views.

🏛️ History & Ownership

Tuckers Tavern is part of the Fearless Restaurants group, known for curating distinctive dining experiences across the Jersey Shore and Pennsylvania. Inspired by classic American taverns and English pubs, Tuckers Tavern was reimagined to blend coastal charm with elevated gastropub sensibilities. The restaurant aims to deliver hearty, creative fare in a welcoming, waterfront setting.

🍽️ Food & Culinary Style

  • Cuisine: American Coastal Gastropub with raw bar offerings and seasonal specials.
  • Quality & Ingredients: Emphasis on fresh-caught local seafood, farm-to-table ingredients, and chef-crafted daily specials.
  • Preparation Style: Dishes are thoughtfully composed with global influences—e.g., muhammara, curried cauliflower, and French lentils.
  • Signature Dishes:
    • Pan Roasted Local Scallops with French lentils and pomegranate
    • Grilled Center Cut Filet Mignon
    • Raw Bar selections including oysters and clams
  • Organic/Farm-to-Table: While not exclusively organic, the menu reflects seasonal sourcing and natural ingredients.

👨‍🍳 The Culinary Team

The culinary team is known for executing a creative, hearty, and comforting menu that aligns with Fearless Restaurants’ high standards. The style leans toward elevated tavern fare with global accents.

🌅 Ambiance & Décor

  • Style: Upscale rustic with nautical themes—think weathered wood, maritime accents, and cozy lighting
  • Vibe: Casual yet refined; ideal for both relaxed lunches and festive dinners.
  • Striking Features:
    • Large square bar as a social centerpiece
    • Rooftop deck with sunset views
    • Live music during happy hour
  • Noise Level: Moderate to lively, especially during peak hours and entertainment.
  • Outdoor Dining: Available seasonally with scenic marina views.
  • Table Spacing: Comfortable, with a mix of communal and private seating.

🤝 Service

  • Staffing: Friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable.
  • Consistency: Service is generally reliable, with staff engagement and food timing.

🍸 Other Features

  • Alcohol/Bar: Full-service bar with 20+ craft beers from breweries like Dogfish Head, Rogue, and Victory
  • Child-Friendly: Welcoming to families, though ambiance leans more adult-friendly during evenings.
  • Recommended For:
    • Groups, couples, and tourists seeking vibrant, scenic dining
    • Happy hour enthusiasts and seafood lovers
  • Not Recommended For:
    • Diners preferring quiet, BYOB, or low-key family-style settings
  • Parking: Street and nearby lot parking available.
  • Dress Code: Casual to smart casual.
  • Holiday Hours: Open year-round, including Thanksgiving, Christmas, Easter, and Mother’s Day

🔧 Areas for Improvement

  • Wait Times: Can be long during peak summer weekends.
  • Noise Levels: May be too lively for those seeking a quiet meal.
  • Reservations: Limited availability during high season; walk-ins often required.

🌟 What Sets Them Apart

Tuckers Tavern distinguishes itself with:

  • A rooftop deck and marina and sunset views
  • A robust craft beer program
  • Creative coastal gastropub fare
  • Year-round service and holiday availability

Whether you're sipping oysters at happy hour or enjoying filet mignon with a sunset backdrop, Tuckers Tavern delivers a uniquely spirited Long Beach Island experience.

Updated October 2025

How We Review Restaurants?

Our Restaurant Rating Criteria to Ensure Minimum Subjective Evaluation