Fare: Traditional American/Seafood
Price: Moderate - Expensive
Food Quality: Decent, many of the dishes are over sauced, overwhelming the ingredients. A notch below the quality of food served at Cape May's top seafood restaurants restaurants
Service: Attentive, but inconsistent, depends on server.
Abiance/Decor: Seventies era steak house atmosphere with three nautical themed dining rooms and walls adorned with murals and photos.
Overall Rating: 2 Stars
Note: Four star Rating System from 1/2 star = poor to Four stars = Best in Class
Noise Level: Moderate
Recommended For: Diners who enjoy traditional American food with "Old World" nautical ambiance
Not Recommended For: Budget conscious diners who prefer more casual dining with large portion servings; or for diners who enjoy an eclectic menu.
Recommended dishes: When available, The Center Cut Filet Topped with Spiced Crawfish and Topped with Sauce Choron; The Andouille Crusted Grouper grouper filet, smoked andouille crust, over rice pilaf with a lemon chive beurre blanc; and The Blackended Swordfish topped with a crab and cucumber salad over basmati rice & herb oil.
Alcohol: Full Bar Service, bar scene is vibrant
Oyster Bay Bar & Restaurant is a popular Cape May restaurant that serves up a mix of traditional American dishes with a well-stocked bar.
The decor is a seventies era steak house styled, with three nautical themed dining rooms and walls adorned with murals and photos. The bar area, recently remodeled, is vibrant with an excellent bar staff. They offer an excellent wine and Martini list.
The menu consists of traditional seafood, meat, and poultry dishes prepared with little creativity using standard, easily available ingredients.
The service is friendly and attentive, but can be inconsistent, or slow on busy summer evenings.
There is free on-site parking, though on busy summer evenings, it can quickly fill up.
Reservations are suggested as they tend to be packed during the peak summer months.
During the summer months, Oyster Bay is open six days/week for dinner. Closed on Monday
(Updated: May 2023)
New Jersey Leisure Guide strives to provide analytic restaurant reviews.
The methodology used is research, analysis driven --- as opposed to that of a single restaurant critic or a social media platform, viewer comment posting board.