Oyster Bay Restaurant & Bar,
Cape May, NJ: A Restaurant Review
Oyster Bay Restaurant
615 Lafayette
Cape May, NJ
Oyster Bay Restaurant Highlights
Fare: Traditional American/Seafood
Price: Moderate - Expensive
Food Quality: Decent, many of the dishes are over sauced, overwhelming the ingredients. A notch below the quality of food served at Cape May's top seafood restaurants restaurants
Service: Attentive, but inconsistent, depends on server.
Abiance/Decor: Seventies era steak house atmosphere with three nautical themed dining rooms and walls adorned with murals and photos.
Overall Rating: 2 Stars
Note: Four star Rating System from 1/2 star = poor to Four stars = Best in Class
Noise Level: Moderate
Dress: Casual
Recommended For: Diners who enjoy traditional American food with "Old World" nautical ambiance
Not Recommended For: Budget conscious diners who prefer more casual dining with large portion servings; or for diners who enjoy an eclectic menu.
Recommended dishes: When available, The Center Cut Filet Topped with Spiced Crawfish and Topped with Sauce Choron; The Andouille Crusted Grouper grouper filet, smoked andouille crust, over rice pilaf with a lemon chive beurre blanc; and The Blackended Swordfish topped with a crab and cucumber salad over basmati rice & herb oil.
Alcohol: Full Bar Service, bar scene is vibrant
Oyster Bay Bar & Restaurant is a well-loved spot in Cape May, offering a blend of classic American cuisine and a fully stocked bar.
The interior has a retro, '70s steakhouse vibe, featuring three nautical-themed dining rooms decorated with murals and maritime photos. The recently renovated bar area is lively and welcoming, complemented by a top-notch bar staff and a strong selection of wines and martinis.
The menu focuses on familiar seafood, meat, and poultry dishes. While the preparations lean toward the traditional and use standard ingredients, the offerings are satisfying for those seeking classic flavors.
Service is generally friendly and attentive, though it can occasionally be slow during peak summer evenings.
Oyster Bay is family-friendly, with a dedicated kids’ menu.
Free on-site parking is available, though it tends to fill up quickly during the busy season.
Reservations are recommended, especially during the summer months when the restaurant is often at capacity.
Hours and days of operation vary by season.
(Updated: April 2025)
Our Restaurant Rating Criteria to Ensure Minimum Subjective Evaluation
